The Guardian
trending topics
Close Box

Our news

Yes, it’s true: We are joining GigaOM...


As Macy’s Stores Went Away, So Did Its Newspaper Ads

  • Comments Comments (View)
  • Text Size: A A

Aside from classified advertising, retail advertising is one of the pillars of newspaper advertising. But as Alan Mutter points out, citing data from TNS and AdAge, Macy’s has cut the amount of newspaper ad spending in half over the past four years. While classified ad dollars have largely shifted to online sites like Craigslist, Macy’s migration away from newspapers has more to do with specific business decisions that make it difficult to imagine newspapers recapturing those lost retail dollars.

Back to 2005: When Macy’s, then known as Federated, merged with Mays department stores in 2005, the two were buying a combined $1.2 billion worth of newspaper ads. At that time, Macy’s operated about 400 stores, while May’s ran roughly 500. Three years later, the combined entity, which has roughly 800 stores, spent just $583.3 million with newspapers, a drop of 51.4 percent. That decline reflected two things: a cutback in stores combined with cost slashing all around. After the merger was complete, Macy’s closed a number of “redundant” stores across the country, which hit local papers hard. This past January, Macy’s said it would close another 11 stores nationwide, AP reported at the time.

Going national: In addition to store closings, since the merger, Macy’s strategy is focused on making the department store chain more of a national brand—shutting off the individual identities that sometimes meant multiple Sunday inserts for different brands. That alsp has meant a shift from local newspapers to more TV and magazines. That change has been starkly reflected in Macy’s ad budget. Four years ago, Macy’s put 71 percent of its ad budget in newspapers; at the end of ‘08, it devoted 59 percent ad dollars. During that period, Macy’s TV ad spend grew from 17 percent of its budget to 27 percent. Macy’s has long used national TV for special promotions, such as its perennial—and expensive—Thanksgiving Day Parade and the July 4th fireworks events, it has a solid platform to build its national branding strategy. As for newspapers, while local papers will have to rely more heavily on local retailers, publishers do have chance to capture at least some of Macy’s national ad spend, albeit through a third party national alliances such as those run by Yahoo and quadrantONE.

Jul 6, 2009 12:17 PM ET

Macy's Ad Decline Photo: AP Images


Posted In: Advertising, Local, Media & Publishing, Newspapers, Research & Metrics, Research

(Page 1 of 1)


The Bestsellers

From iTunes and YouTube to Facebook and Kindle, the most popular content on the web, free and paid.

iTunes TV Shows iTunes TV Shows
1. Dangerous Liasons
2. All You Need Is Love
3. Welcome to Westfield
4. Me? Jealous?
5. Tarentella
See The Other Bestsellers »

Jobs RSS Job Listings

Social Standing

Which media brands are getting a lift from Tweeters and bloggers right now -- and which are getting panned?

"Sentiment" Scores for All the Companies »

Sponsors

Staff