The Guardian
topics
Close Box

News From Us:

Our latest report; our new video section; and jobs with paidContent.org and paidContent:UK


Five Reasons Why Microsoft Does Not Need To Worry About Google Chrome OS

Microsoft (NSDQ: MSFT) still hasn’t commented on Google’s plans to introduce an operating system of its own. An official statement is coming later today and we’ll post it here when it comes out. (Update: Microsoft now says it will in fact not comment). But there are lots of reasons why Microsoft does not need to be too concerned about Google’s foray into its home turf. Here are five:

Windows 7 is not Vista: Google’s operating system, which is initially targeted for netbooks, will only be available starting in mid-2010. By then, Microsoft’s new operating system, Windows 7, will have been on the market for at least nine months. Unlike its predecessor Windows Vista, Windows 7 has received rave early reviews. Also unlike Vista, Microsoft has promised that Windows 7 will work as well on netbooks as on high-end gaming PCs. As one Microsoft employee wrote on his blog today, “If Win7 didn’t have a SKU for Netbooks, this might even be interesting.” Microsoft will therefore be in a strong position to defend its turf than when Chrome OS comes out

Microsoft is building its own browser optimized to run web apps: Like Google (NSDQ: GOOG), Microsoft understands that more people are running applications from within the browser—and is moving quickly to adapt its products to that reality. The company’s research arm, Microsoft Research, is developing a new browser called Gazelle, which it describes as a “browser-based OS” optimized to run web apps. Just last week, the company put out a summary of the principles behind the project.

Chrome OS will compete with Ubuntu: Chrome OS—which is open source—will further fragment the open source operating system market, since it will provide yet another option, writes Renai LeMay at ZDNet. This comes just as Ubuntu was becoming the dominant choice. He writes, “In this context, Google’s decision to create its own Linux distribution and splinter the Linux community decisively ... can only be seen as foolhardy and self-obsessive.” That could obviously benefit Microsoft.

Are consumers ready for a life on the web? Most of the user experience in Chrome OS will take place on the web, so it’s not likely that computers with the operating system installed will be able to run any Windows applications. That will likely limit adoption. Writes Bernstein Research’s Jeffrey Lindsay, “Google would need to rely on people to more fully adopt web-based services (a long-dated proposition), or for software developers to port their applications over to Chrome OS.”

Google’s track record outside of search is poor: Google has launched other high-profile attacks on Microsoft products, with only limited success so far. The company has gone after Office with Google Docs and Internet Explorer with Chrome. Both products may have generated lots of buzz but not much market share. And, of course, Microsoft is also going on the offensive, with its revamped search engine Bing, which directly targets Google’s core business.

Related Stories
Jul 8, 2009 5:45 PM ET

Chrome vs. Windows

Share

Posted In: Technologies / Formats, Operating Systems, Companies, Google, Microsoft

  • Schoschie

    I see why this site is called paidcontent.org. It's content paid for by Microsoft (NSDQ: MSFT).

  • rawbobb

    1) windows 7 IS Vista Service pack 3.  Everyone in the IT industry knows this.

    2) Microsoft insists on not following Web standards for their browsers.  People are flocking to Firefox, as they will for Chrome.

    3) Chrome will compete with Ubuntu? Who cares.  Chrome may lower the price of a Netbook 15%.  The economy's bad, 15% is real and measurable.

    4) Who's going to buy MS office at $450 when the netbook costs $450? Google apps may very well be "free" on their OS.  A whole generation under 30 isn't worried about their data on the internet.  That generation will just get larger.  They Do, however, know the difference between $450 and Free.

    5) Track record?  For every failure of Google there is 50 from microsoft.  Please. 

    It's Goliath vs. Goliath, as long as they both have tons of cash to burn. 

    The difference between MS and Google is that Google (in perception at least) embraces "open" while MS embraces themselves.

    I'm happy that this article was short.  If you guys need a better crap storm topic let me know.  Thank you.

  • <a >JLO

    As Google moves further away from its core area of seach, they risk build an aversion to their products and some paranoid users…

  • ed dunn

    I have to admit, this is an interesting move. It's like Google just walked by and pushed the Ubuntu and other Linux OS developers off the road into the mud - the same people who would have been a great partner…

    Trying to split the Linux developers and open source communities will only help Microsoft. No one in business is going to touch it if they see linux and google developers/loyalists scrapping it out at SlashDot and ZDNET….

  • Joseph Tartakoff

    Hi Wade,

    Thanks so much for writing those up. Those are fair counter-points. I look forward to seeing what happens.

    Joe Tartakoff, paidContent.org

  • Wade

    There are a quite a few assumptions and problems with this article, and the only real point that has any merit is the first about Windows 7 being a better contender in the marketplace than Vista was.  I have outlined my arguments here: http://wadetandy.com/2009/07/five-reasons-microsoft-should-still-fear-google/

  • It is an interesting move, but something that has been rumoured for so long it was just a matter of time.  But the move to further split the linux market and slow the possible growth of Ubuntu is a shame. 

    As Google moves further away from its core area of seach, they risk build an aversion to their products and some paranoid users…

    If Google OS knows what time you boot up your PC, how long it takes for you to open up Chrome, when you Googled a product, which you found what you were looking for in the results shown as an Adword.  You now visit the online store running Google Analytics to pay via Google Checkout… how much is this going to rise some anti-trust issues…

    Oh forgot that the confirmation of online purchase was send to your Google voice number which you later read on your Google Android phone number…

    http://thelostagency.wordpress.com

The Economics of Content | paidContent Newsletter

Know something we don’t?

Send Us a News Tip

All tips are anonymous and untraced.

Sponsors

Contributors