The Guardian
topics
Close Box

News From Us:

Our latest report; our new video section; and jobs with paidContent.org and paidContent:UK


Razorfish’s Lanctot: Flexibility’s A Double-Edged Sword For Online; Don’t Count Out Display

As it has for pretty much every industry, this has been a dizzying few weeks for online advertising. Turmoil stemming from the global banking crisis and the volatility in the financial markets has only made the year-long ad recession appear even darker than first anticipated. To get a sense of how digital ad execs are reacting to the dismal economic news as of late, PEHub asked Jeff Lanctot, chief strategy officer for Microsoft’s Razorfish (the Avenue A part of the name was cut off this week), about layoffs, shrinking ad budgets, ad nets and the value of display.

A double-edged sword: The speed and flexibility of online ads is a “blessing and curse.” With most print and TV ad buys locked in months in advance, marketers are taking out the carving knife to online ad budgets simply because it’s easier to adjust spending there. But Lanctot insists that’s just the near-term. As marketers take a broader look at their priorities and where the crucial ROI is, online ad spending will fare better than traditional media. Nevertheless, expectations of online ad spend being flat appear optimistic right now. More on display, ad nets and layoffs after the jump.

Forget click-throughs: While display ad spending has slowed considerably over the past several months, with prospects for greater sluggishness widely anticipated, Lanctot says that display’s virtues haven’t been accurately measured. For one thing, click-through rates are not the best metric. People are not likely to click the first time they see an ad, but like a TV commercial or a roadside billboard, display builds familiarity with a brand, he contends. And above all, Lanctot believes that display’s direct response does represent a concrete action taken by the consumer that will be more appreciated by marketers as the downturn gets deeper.

Boom times end for ad nets: The feeling that a glut existed around remnant ad nets would soon lead to consolidation and death for many operators has been expected for a while. Lanctot’s take: “There are probably more than 300 ad networks up and running and they aren’t differentiated on technology. It’s all about arbitrage; they buy inventory for a low price and sell it for a higher price and add little value in between. I think there will be a real shakeup in that business over the next year. In a downturn, it becomes imperative for people to become more efficient, and in an efficient marketplace, I don’t think there is room for these players. I’d guess that dozens and dozens of ad networks won’t make it through the next year.”

On layoffs: Lanctot has been with the company since 1999, which gave him plenty of time to get the full view of the dot-com bubble burst. The company went through layoffs in 2001. He doesn’t answer the question directly, saying it depends on what clients do—how much they cut back and whether or not the survive. In the meantime, Razorfish—as is every ad agency—is at the mercy of marketers’ contingency plans. “The trickle-down for us is once they’re settled on their needs from us… obviously influences our planning. It’s premature to react now until we have a better sense of how our client’s services will be impacted, but I think 2009 is going to be a tough year.”

Oct 22, 2008 11:54 PM ET
Share

Posted In: Advertising, Companies, Microsoft, jeff lanctot, razorfish

The Economics of Content | paidContent Newsletter

Know something we don’t?

Send Us a News Tip

All tips are anonymous and untraced.

Sponsors

Contributors